Credit card or personal loan?
Put the same monthly amount towards a card balance or a fixed-term personal loan and compare the time and the total cost.
Figures checked on 17 November 2026. Sources and dates
The short answer
$5,000.00 on a 20.95% card costs $1,270.66 in interest at $239.83 a month. A 13.9% loan over 24 months at that payment costs $755.88.
Worked example: $5,000.00 on a card at 20.95%, against a loan at 13.9% over 24 months with no fee. Change any figure to see your own.
Card $1,270.66 over 2 years 3 months; loan $755.88 over 2 years
| Card | Personal loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | $239.83 | $239.83 (last $239.79) |
| Time to clear | 2 years 3 months | 2 years |
| Interest | $1,270.66 | $755.88 |
| Fees | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| Total cost | $1,270.66 | $755.88 |
- The card uses the same monthly payment as the loan, so the two are compared on the same outlay.
- The loan's fee is added to the amount borrowed. Its payment is rounded to the cent, and the last payment clears what is left.
- A loan has a fixed end date; a card balance only falls if you stop using the card. General information, not financial advice.
How the comparison works
The loan payment is the amount that clears the loan, plus any establishment fee added to it, over the term, rounded to the cent; the last payment clears what is left. The card is paid at the same amount each month under the site's standard model, unless you enter a different card payment.
Published personal loan terms
Main bank terms as read on 17 November 2026, listed A to Z. A gap means the figure could not be confirmed from the bank's own page.
| Bank | Rate | Establishment fee |
|---|---|---|
| ANZ | See bank (not confirmed) | $0 |
| ASB | 13.9% | $0 |
| BNZ | 12.9% | $50 |
| Westpac | 13.9% | $0 |
| Kiwibank (provided by Latitude Financial Services) | 18.95% | $199 |
Sources: ASB personal loans, BNZ personal loan, Westpac personal loans terms, Kiwibank personal loans, ANZ personal loan rates. No Reserve Bank average was available.
Things a calculator cannot weigh
- A loan has a fixed end date; a card balance falls only if you stop using the card.
- Loans can have early repayment terms; cards let you pay off any time.
- A new loan application adds an enquiry to your credit report (credit cards and your score).
- Kiwibank adds its fee to the loan; BNZ charges a facility fee (Kiwibank personal loans; BNZ personal loan).
See also the debt consolidation calculator for several debts. General information, not financial advice.
Sources
- ASB personal loans
- BNZ personal loan, rates and fees table
- Westpac personal loans terms, fees and rates
- Kiwibank personal loans (provided by Latitude Financial Services)
- ANZ personal loan rates, fees and agreements
- Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003
Checked 17 November 2026. General information, not financial advice. Spotted an error? Email crucibleinvestmentsltd@gmail.com.
Questions
Is a personal loan cheaper than a credit card?
Often the rate is lower, but fees and the term matter. The calculator compares the total cost on the same monthly outlay.
Should I close the card after moving the balance?
That is your decision. Leaving the limit open keeps it counted in affordability checks, and new spending adds to what you owe.
Does the loan fee change the result?
Yes. A fee added to the loan is borrowed too and attracts interest; the calculator includes it in both the payment and the total cost.
Related calculators
Credit card interest calculator
Work out credit card interest the way NZ banks do: daily on the balance, on a statement where you paid short, or on a cash advance from day one.
Open →Balance transfer calculator
Does a balance transfer save you money? Compare staying put with a promotional rate, any transfer fee and the revert rate, at the same monthly payment.
Open →Credit card cost finder
Enter how you spend and see what a year with each NZ credit card would cost you in fees, foreign fees and interest, from dated published terms. No rankings.
Open →Rewards and annual fee calculator
Do your credit card rewards or Airpoints cover the annual fee? Enter your own spending, earn rate and point value to see the net result and break-even.
Open →Credit limit and borrowing calculator
See how an unused credit card limit counts when you apply for a home loan: debt-to-income with and without the card, and how lenders allow for limits.
Open →High-cost credit check
Check whether a credit contract is high-cost credit under the CCCFA: a rate of 50% or more, including default interest, with the caps that then apply.
Open →